Zac Kandell (known mostly on the internet as Mischlings) thinks he knows how deep the rabbit hole of Star Wars EU goes, but is probably wrong. If you find what he says interesting, follow him on Twitter at @Mischlings or check out his personal blog.
Zac Kandell (known mostly on the internet as Mischlings) thinks he knows how deep the rabbit hole of Star Wars EU goes, but is probably wrong. If you find what he says interesting, follow him on Twitter at @Mischlings or check out his personal blog.
I think that what’s bugging me the most, if anything, is that there are a few too many storylines going on all at once. When I get to the end of an issue, while each story there may have come to a good stopping point to be picked up again in the next issue, the issues don’t feel like they’re full, standalone stories. Good or bad, this series is being written for the trade, at which point it should make a lot more sense. As for now, there’s a bit too much going on.
I was frustratingly vague in my review of issue #1 of this series. A lot of that was due to the fear that Dark Horse would send someone with a lightsaber to my apartment if I spoiled anything, but also because the idea alone carried the issue and my recommendation. However, now that the novelty has worn off, does The Star Wars #2 (written by JW Rinzler, illustrated by Mike Mayhew) carry itself with the story rather than just the concept?
![]() |
I just had to post the Ralph McQuarrie cover. |
I don’t hold Star Wars up as the foundation of my childhood or The Holy Trilogy (that belongs to Lord of the Rings), so I really wanted to see the different interpretations of these characters. While I still like it, this series is caught in a weird Catch-22 – it wouldn’t exist without the Star Wars name and is too much of a rip-off to exist on its own. Problem is, existing in the middle tends to just make things more confusing. The biggest issue is how much the characters are modeled after the actors – this Princess Leia looks like Carrie Fisher while acting nothing like her Leia, this Annikin looks like an older Hayden Christensen but is nothing like him. Just a change in the art, designing those characters to look different than their (somewhat) counterparts from the movies would go a long way towards avoiding confusion.
Big Star Wars fans are about to be pissed off at really stupid things, which I realize now should be the definition of fans. There are some familiar characters introduced here with a very different take than people are used to. Now, that can be said for everyone, but these are particularly beloved characters, and anything that’s changed about them is going to bring the angry fans out in droves, assuming that they’re reading this in the first place. While it caught me off-guard, I believe that changes shouldn’t be condemned automatically, and since the spirit of the characters is still intact, I’m willing to roll with it and actually enjoy seeing a different take.
The story in this issue is also a little unclear. The biggest problem is that it’s trying to hit on a lot of beats from the original movie (as much as I’d like to avoid the comparisons, they’re simply impossible not to make), but they play out in a different but unforunately unclear way. I’m also wondering how much ground of the original trilogy is going to be covered in this series, in their very compressed way. I thought this was just going to cover the ground of Star Wars, but this issue is making me think it’s going to cover a lot more.
Overall, I give this a tentative recommendation, only $3.99 after all. I have enough faith in it for now that my subscription is still going, but the novelty is wearing off and the rest of the story hasn’t yet stepped up to compensate. If you’re not in on it yet, this won’t convince you, but if you’re already reading it, you’ll want to keep going.
Zac Kandell (known mostly on the internet as Mischlings) tried writing this review purely in beeps and whistles, but the speech recognition software didn’t like that idea. If you find what he says interesting, follow him on Twitter at @Mischlings for more, shorter thoughts.
Yes, The Star Wars #1 (written by J. W. Rinzler, illustrated by Mike Mayhew) is a Star Wars book. I’m not sure how to fit it into the Expanded Universe canon, if that’s even possible or necessary to. None of that matters, however, and I recommend that anyone who has even a passing interest in the concept pick it up: this is based on the original screenplay that George Lucas wrote in 1974, before many of the changes that made Star Wars what it eventually became.
This is why I say it’s not important to try and figure out how it fits into the canon – call it an alternate universe or something else, just take the concept and run with it. While I’d prefer the franchise in general to completely leave behind the Skywalker family, this is a good way to approach it. A lot of the things that you’re familiar with are gone (and I tried looking for them – they’re either gone or we’re just not there yet), so just take the basic ideas of how the Star Wars Universe works and run with it. It’s difficult to say what’s different because of spoiler limitations, but even knowing that this was based on a completely different version of the movie, I was surprised by how different it was.
A big difference that caught me off-guard was the different entry point into the universe. I expected an opening on Tattooine with Luke, or maybe even the actual opening to the movie with R2-D2 and C-3PO on the Tantive IV. Instead, it starts by going more behind the scenes of the rebellion going on when the original movie started. It serves the purpose of showing the actual events in the opening crawl that Star Wars made famous instead of just using said opening crawl, which may be a rather controversial decision depending on the fans you ask. Don’t worry about its complete absence, though – there is a half-page text crawl setting up the universe at the beginning as if you were completely unfamiliar with it, which applies to very few people but still is a nice touch.
I’m not entirely decided on the art style in this book. As I lack a good art background, I’m not entirely sure how to describe it, but there’s something about the way that faces are drawn that bugs me somewhat. They just look slightly off, but it could just be that it’s a stylistic choice that I won’t even notice after a couple issues have passed, it’s just something worth notice.
Overall, I recommend picking up this book. I know that I haven’t gone into too many specifics, but I don’t think you really need it at this point. It’s a really interesting idea to use the old draft of the script, especially when so many things from that script have been the “what might have been” about the series for decades, that I think just starting to see what it’s becoming is worth the $3.99 cover price. So long as you know that you probably won’t get exactly what you’re expecting, you’ll probably enjoy it.
Zac Kandell (known mostly on the internet as Mischlings) now has something else to add to his pull list. Somehow, getting free comics is really expensive. If you find what he says interesting, follow him on Twitter at @Mischlings for more, shorter thoughts.
This is the issue that I’ve been waiting for since this series started: Darth Vader vs. the Assassin. Because if you saw the massacre the assassin pulled off in the first issue, you’ve been exited to see this fight since they revealed the room full of dead soldiers. Better yet, this issue isn’t just about the fight, but gives a nice, tidy close to this story arch. Read more after the jump.
I’ve comment in a couple of my previous reviews of this series that I was seeing a side of Darth Vader that I didn’t feel like I saw in the movies: a stead hand, an diplomatic approach and so on, contrasted with a picture I’ve always held in my head of a cold hearted warrior obsessed with power. The Vader I thought I knew is back. And I’m loving it. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve enjoyed the more well rounded view of his character, but this just feels like what I want from a Darth Vader-centric comic. We even get the “join the dark side” speech.
Even with that side playing a bigger part, we get some of the cunning and cleverness that helps make him a more fleshed out character as he wraps up loose ends. Some monologuing from the emperor (which for once I didn’t feel was too long winded for the pace) and all in all, I have to say I’m pleased with how this story ends.
The art is spectacular, as it has been. I have less to say about the art really, because this is one of the things that has been consistently good about this series. I marveled in my first review at how the style and feel of Star Wars fit despite the introduction of characters and even races that were entirely new. Major props to the entire art team, Ivan Fernandez in particular as the penciller and earlier .
When I first started reviewing this, I was less than excited about this series. I was worried that I wouldn’t really be so interested because of course the assassin must fail in his task for the continuity to be maintained. In the end, I found myself really liking the series, but this issue was without a doubt the best of the five issues. After all of this, I finally recommend this series with enthusiasm. If you’ve been following the series thus far, without a doubt go get this issue, especially for $3.50. If you haven’t, go find the old issues to re-read. There is a collection coming out, but it’s $7.50 more than buying the issues independently. Not worth it just for the convenience.
Matthew Bryant, a.k.a. Baker Street Holmes, is a writer and editor for the Red Shirt Crew and so glad for this blog for giving him something to do when he can’t possibly work on his thesis anymore. He’s excited to be almost done with that, and is looking forward to returning to the States. You can follow him on Twitter at @BStreetHolmes or e-mail him at HMCrazySS@gmail.com.
Darth Vader and the Ninth Assassin is back this week and I thought much more interesting than it has been (although, as I pointed out last time, it has started to interest me more now that the Headless Snake Cultists have become a bigger thing). There are folds of how this fits into the larger picture beginning to unfurl and we’re getting some answers to things I never thought to ask about the Star Wars stories. Really good stuff this month!
I harped on the second issue of A Tale of the Golem‘s cover for portraying something that has nothing to do with the plot of that issue, and it’s only fair that I point out the same here: there are no big toothy monsters in this issue. None. This is a cover for the last issue, if you ask me. The cover from the last issue was about the one before that, too. It’s a beautiful cover, but it’s just not right for this issue. Minor quibble, but if you’re looking for monsters, read the last issue, not this one.
Now, about the actual issue: this comic really caught my attention because we see things with clear tie ins to the main film series like a glimpse at Vader’s eventual fight with Obi Wan and maybe some hint as to the beginnings of the death star? We also learn more about the Cult of the Headless Snake, its origins and the ancient prophesy at its core. I’ve really been looking forward to learning more about this cult and I’m glad they got around to it so quickly. Now that we know about them though, I wonder what role they will play, if any, since they are no longer a mystery. I hope they aren’t just done.
But I suspect they will, because otherwise this issue would be completely unrelated to the Assassing part of the title. Yeah, forgot about that with all the talk of cultists and death stars and monsters, didn’t you? Yeah, well this series is still apparently about Darth Vader and an assassin, though the assassin has been a background character for the past three issues. The next issue’s cover shows them fighting, but we’ve already discussed how trustworthy the covers in this series can be.
So the ultimate question: do I recommend this issue? Yes, actually, because if you’re following the series, it has some important plot development (the cultist details) that you’re going to want to know. And even if you aren’t following the series, but are interested in the lore behind Star Wars it’s worth picking up because the plot for this issue stands alone fairly well and has some interesting connections to the original movie trilogy. Besides, what’s $3.50? Like only, like, 35 minutes of minimum wage work.
Matthew Bryant, aka Baker Street Holmes, is an editor for the Red Shirt Crew and enjoys long walks on the beach, steam summer sales and AIR CONDITIONING, which the British people have apparently never heard of. If you wish to provide him with AC or even just a large bag of ice, you can reach him on Twitter at @BStreetHolmes or e-mail him at HMCrazySS@gmail.com.
We continue with Darth Vader and his quest to save the Emperor from an assassin. That actually wants to kill him. But tried to fail to kill the emperor, so he could kill Vader. You know, what? Just go read the earlier issues, or at least my reviews for #1 and #2. A lot has happened.
Vader is hunting down the Cult of the Headless Snake. Well, that’s not what they call it, but they haven’t revealed what it is called yet, so that’s going to have to suffice. In his travels, he comes across the shattered star destroyer from the previous issue and learns of the headless snake cultist who lead/directed the attack. Following data on the ship’s logs, Vader travels to the nearby moon to seek the source of the attack, and hopefully the assassination attempt. What he doesn’t know is that he’s got a second shadow that follows him to the surface.
What I find interesting, and this may just be because my knowledge of Darth Vader is of the aggressive combatant from the movies, but he is very much a detective and investigator in this issue. Don’t get me wrong, he still fights off some creatures in a classic display of lightsaber and force power prowess, but his role as a fighter is a minor aspect in this issue. I really liked seeing him in a different character role, at least different to what I usually see.
Also, we see a little bit more, just a little bit, of this “Cult of the Headless Snake”, right at the end, and no spoilers, but I’m very, very intrigued now. Before this, I was just wondering if they were with the assassin or not. Now, I have about a billion questions (or really closer to seven) about who they are and what their story is. I’ve commented in my past articles about this series and that I have had a hard time really getting invested because the movies meant that Darth Vader obviously survives, so Vader and this mysterious assassin aren’t that interesting. We more or less know how things turn out. But these cultists: who knows what they do! They could have any number of outcomes! That alone has made this my favorite issue of the series thus far.
The last couple issues I didn’t really give an enthusiastic recommendation for because of that. This time I can definitely give a recommendation, because this time, it’s actually worth the $3.50 they want for it. You don’t miss much from the previous issue/you catch up on a lot of it in this one, but I would recommend reading the first issue, because there are some characters that may or may not come up later (honestly, I don’t know yet) that are only shown there, so far.
Matthew Bryant, aka Baker Street Holmes, is an editor for the Red Shirt Crew, and a lover of all things nerdy. Except zombies, because they could kill you. They’re fine in movies, books and games, but actual zombies are not to be loved. You can follow him on Twitter at @BStreetHolmes or e-mail him at HMCrazySS@g-mail.com.
So, in my last review of Darth Vader and the Ninth Assassin, I was a little hesitant to recommend the comic, as it was unclear where it was going. Reading the second issue has cleared up some of my questions, but I’m still less than thrilled with it. What went wrong now? Check it out after the jump.Despite my uncertainty last time, the comic did shift focus from the assassin to Darth Vader, which I think makes the comic a more compelling read, since the main character isn’t expected to fail anymore. And we see an attempt on the Emperor’s life that lures Darth Vader out into the open, so they’ve at least started the true action of the story. Even the star destroyer that gets attacked, teased on the Dark Horse page for the comic, is pretty spectacular. But as I noted last time, I still have trouble getting really excited about anything from this time period in the canon, particularly in regards to Vader, because we know he lives to see the original trilogy.
I also feel like there are a lot of wasted frames in this comic. The attempt on the Emperor’s life is about two pages too long. The conversation the two of them have at the end could also have been more concise. It felt sort of like the Tim Siedell had a three comic story in mind, but Dark Horse gave him more than that (up to issue #5 can be pre-ordered on Dark Horse already) and he went “Oh, um, okay, I guess I can leave some blank pages for Stephen Thompson to draw on then…” Overall, it just hinders the pacing, and the whole thing feels kind of slow.
As much as I’m complaining, it is not all bad. I still like the art; Thompson does a great job. There is also a bit of mystery to the story, as the assassin is never actually said to be behind either of the attacks, and in fact, the attack on the star destroyer doesn’t even really help his cause much, but seems to be perpetrated by the same people who tried to kill the emperor. Is one of the other eight assassins going to make an appearance? The first comic did say they weren’t all accounted for. Or is the ninth assassin really behind that too? Maybe he has his own agenda. Honestly, it’s my curiosity over these minor matters that are keeping me reading for at least one more comic, not the main plot.
I still can only give a “so-so” recommendation, because I just find it so hard getting drawn into this time period in Star Wars with anything less than an enthralling plot hook. But if you want it, it’s $3.50. I’ll be back in a month with issue 3.
Matthew Bryant, aka Baker Street Holmes, just learned that not only might Jar Jar make a return in Episode VII, Robert Pattinson has expressed interest in lending his voice to the role. Holmes would love to see Binks die a horrible, painful death more than ever. You can follow Holmes on Twitter at @BStreetHolmes or e-mail him at HMCrazySS@gmail.com.
As some of you may know tomorrow (Saturday May 4, 2013) is the 11th annual FREE COMIC BOOK DAY! If you no longer care about what I have to say about free comics, because you are too excited and want to get your comic right now, you are free to leave. Free comic book day isn’t about you. Free comic book day is all about those who aren’t yet comic fans.We read a lot of comics around the Red Shirt Crew office, in case you didn’t notice. Personally, I love that part of our job, because I grew up with comics and comic book characters. But maybe you’ve never really gotten into them, perhaps you never understood the draw.
That’s precisely why Free Comic Book Day exists, so people like yourself have a chance to pick up a comic or two (or five, if you’re at a well stocked store) and give it a shot and see what you think. But just because the offer is there, doesn’t mean you’re necessarily going to take advantage of this opportunity. That’s why I want to give you 6 reasons to go out and get a comic tomorrow, if you aren’t already a comic fan. If you are a comic reader, some of these will still have useful information for you too so read on!
6. Even if you aren’t a big superhero fan, there are still plenty of comics to choose from!
Tomorrow you can get Superman and Judge Dredd comics, sure, but the video game fans can get a Mass Effect or Sonic the Hedgehog comic, Sci Fi fans can get Star Wars. There are even some television show based comics like Spongebob, The Waking Dead and Grimm. There’s over 50 comics in total involved this year, and while not ever comic shop will have every comic, pretty much any comic shop will have something for you. Which brings us to…
5. Participating locations are easy to find, so don’t fret if you don’t know where your nearest comics book store is and whether or not they are participating.
Just go here, and type in your Zip code (or look up an international location!).
4. Comics are a great way to help kids learn to read.
Maybe you’re not there to get a comic for you. Comics are a great place for kids to start to learn to read. They’re short, they teach good lessons and even when they aren’t free, they’re an inexpensive way to get kids to read regularly.
3. It’s a great way to get introduced to new writers and new series.
Whether or not you are a comic fan already, Free Comic Book Day is a way that you can find writers and series you didn’t know you’d love. Like Neil Gaiman? (note: I don’t think any of the comics this year are from Neil Gaiman) You may not keep reading comics, but you might watch his upcoming episode of Doctor Who or one of his novels, like American Gods. You never know where a single read might take you.
2. Many major comic shops across the United States and around the world are having comic signings by comic writers.
If you’re not a comic reader already, this might be a bit of a stretch reason to go to a Free Comic Book Day event, but many places arrange to have comic book authors in their stores to sign comics that day. This is of course in addition to other events such location might arrange around Free Comic Book Day including other kinds of free merchandise or movie viewings of comic book movies.
1. Because Hugh Jackman told you to.
Matthew Bryant, aka Baker Street Holmes, will not be participating in Free Comic Book Day only because it’s a $28 train ride to the nearest comic shop, and that defeats the point of Free Comic Book day. But he wants that Grimm comic SO MUCH! You can follow him on Twitter at @BStreetHolmes or e-mail him at HMCrazySS@gmail.com.